Common options for sludge disposal and their major advantages and disadvantages are given in table 5.
Disposal option
Advantage
Disadvantage
Landfill
- no spreading of heavy metals
- no nutrient recovery
- danger of groundwater infiltration
Incineration
- phosphorus recovery possible (but rarely done)
- loss of nitrogen
- expensive
Agricultural utilisation
- full nutrient recovery
- cheap fertiliser
- low disposal costs
- heavy metals and organic pollutants are applied, too
- may be pathogens are spread
Application to disturbed land
- concentrated application of heavy metals and organic pollutants
Table 5: Sludge disposal systems and their advantages and disadvantages
Land application is likely to remain as a mayor option for the future, particularly for smaller plants in rural areas which are generally less contaminated by toxic compounds and close to disposal sites. However, agricultural use is subjected to a great variability over time, depending on crop type and weather conditions while sludge production is continuous. For this option, the presence of pathogens, heavy metals and organic contaminants is important. Risks from pathogens can be properly reduced by applying available technologies but costs vary widely depending on product quality criteria, local, social and economical structure. Heavy metals and organic micropollutants arise mainly from chemicals used in industry and households. They can be controlled through cleaner technologies, reduced use and spillage and processes in the treatment works
If agricultural utilisation is taken into account, impact on the Environment and population has to be minimized by
limitation of the applied amount
further limitation of the applied amount according to the crop’s nutrient demand
restrictions for sludge rich in heavy-metals
restricted access to farmland where biosolids have been applied for 30 days
limitation of application to even areas (< 5 % slope)
no application close to water bodies
soil depth to groundwater > 1m
setback distances to water supply wells (> 150 m) and surface water supply
intake (> 750 m)
pathogen reducing treatment (thermophilic processes, composting, humification)
restrictions for the harvesting of crops and turf
As well as for water reuse applications, utilisation of Sewage sludge can be a problem of acceptance in the society. For further information about public awareness see lesson E3.